Photo provided by Robert Deutsch, USA Today
NFL only counts rushing touchdowns, receiving touchdowns, field goals, kick/punt touchdowns, Please note that touchdown passes do not count towards points scored for a college. In NFL calculations for individual points, touchdown passes by quarterbacks are not counted, as the points are assigned to the receiver. There are 142 different colleges that have scored in the Super Bowl, and 2 players that have scored without ever playing college football: Toni Fritsch (Dallas Cowboys) and Garo Yepremian (Miami Dolphins).
The colleges and the points they have scored in the Super Bowl are listed as:
Miami FL: 84 Points
Florida: 82 Points
Penn State: 81 Points
California: 66 Points
Notre Dame: 64 Points
Texas Tech: 62 Points
Georgia: 61 Points
Memphis: 59 Points
T-9. Nebraska & Stanford: 54 Points
Mississippi Valley State: 48 Points
T-12. Illinois & Michigan State: 45 Points
Oklahoma: 44 Points
T-15. Arizona, Ohio State, & USC: 42 Points
UCLA: 39 Points
T-19. NC State & Wisconsin: 38 Points
T-21. Colorado & Florida State: 37 Points
T-23. Pitt & South Dakota State: 34 Points
LSU: 32 Points
Georgia Tech: 31 Points
T-27. Cincinnati, Michigan, Oklahoma State, Syracuse, & Wyoming: 30 Points
Minnesota: 25 Points
T-32. BYU, Kansas, Kansas State, Louisiana Tech, Tulane, & North Carolina: 24 Points
James Madison: 23 Points
Clemson: 22 Points
Texas A&M: 21 Points
T-41. Indiana, Louisville, & Virginia Tech: 20 Points
T-44. Alabama A&M, Chadron State, Tennessee, Washington, & Western Michigan: 18 Points
T-49. Hawaii, Texas, & Utah: 17 Points
T-52. Arizona State, N/A College Affiliation, Temple, & Youngstown State: 16 Points
South Carolina: 15 Points
T-57. New Mexico State, North Dakota State, Oregon, Purdue, & Utah State: 14 Points
Louisiana: 13 Points
T-64. Akron, Cal-Riverside, Delaware State, Eastern Washington, Grambling, Iowa State, Kent State, Lane, Marshall, Mississippi, Northeastern, Philander Smith, Rutgers, Stephen F. Austin, Tennessee State, Texas State, Troy, Tulsa, UNLV, UT-Arlington, Wake Forest, West Texas A&M, West Virginia, and William & Mary: 12 Points
Montana State: 11 Points
T-89. Kentucky & UTEP: 9 Points
Boston College: 8 Points
San Diego State: 7 Points
T-93. Angelo State, Arkansas, Augustana, Austin Peay, Bethune-Cookman, Central Michigan, Colorado Mesa, Delaware, East Carolina, Fresno State, Furman, Harvard, Houston, Iowa, Lambuth, Livingstone, Maryland, Miami (Ohio), Midwestern State, Mississippi State, Missouri, Missouri Southern, Monmouth, Mount Union, Navy, Nevada, New Mexico, Northern Iowa, Portland State, Prairie View, Rice, Santa Clara, SE Louisiana, SMU, South Carolina State, Southern Miss, UMass, Villanova, Wabash, Western Carolina, & Winston-Salem State: 6 Points
Bowling Green: 5 Points
T-135. Auburn & Baylor: 4 Points
Missouri Western State: 3 Points
T-138. Long Beach State, Texas A&M Commerce, Toledo, & Weber State: 2 Points
142. Coast Guard: 1 Point