Updated through Super Bowl LXII. Please note touchdown passes do not count towards points scored for a college. The NFL calculations for individual points do not count touchdown passes quarterbacks as the points are assigned to the receiver. There is a 139 different colleges that have scored in the Super Bowl and 2 players that have scored without ever playing college football. Toni Fritsch (Dallas Cowboys) and Garo Yepremian (Miami Dolphins). 62 out of 69 P5 schools have scored in the Super Bowl, the teams that have not scored include Duke, Northwestern, TCU, UCF, Oregon State, Washington State, Alabama, and Vanderbilt.
- 1. Miami FL: 84 Points
- 2. Florida: 82 Points
- 3. Penn State: 81 Points
- 4. California: 66 Points
- 5. Notre Dame & Oklahoma: 64 Points
- 6. Texas Tech: 62 Points
- 7. Georgia 61 Points
- 8. Memphis: 59 Points
- T-9. Nebraska & Stanford: 54 Points
- 11. Mississippi Valley State: 48 Points
- T-12. Illinois & Michigan State: 45 Points
- T-15. Arizona, Ohio State, & USC: 42 Points
- 18. UCLA: 39 Points
- T-19. NC State & Wisconsin: 38 Points
- T-21. Colorado & Florida State: 37 Points
- T-23. Pitt & South Dakota State: 34 Points
- 25. LSU: 32 Points
- T-26. Cincinnati & Georgia Tech: 30 Points
- T-28. Michigan, Oklahoma State, Syracuse, & Wyoming: 30 Points
- 32. Minnesota: 25 Points
- T-33. BYU, Kansas, Kansas State, Louisiana Tech, Tulane, & North Carolina: 24 Points
- 39. James Madison: 23 Points
- T-39. Clemson & Georgia Tech: 22 Points
- 41. Texas A&M: 21 Points
- T-42. Indiana, Louisville, & Virginia Tech: 20 Points
- T-45. Alabama A&M, Chadron State, Tennessee, Washington, & Western Michigan: 18 Points
- T-49. Hawaii, Texas, & Utah: 17 Points
- T-52. Arizona State, N/A College Affiliation, Temple, & Youngstown State: 16 Points
- 56. South Carolina: 15 Points
- T-57. New Mexico State, North Dakota State, Oregon, Purdue, & Utah State: 14 Points
- 62. Louisiana: 13 Points
- T-63. Akron, Cal-Riverside, Delaware State, Eastern Washington, Grambling, Iowa State, Kent State, Lane, Marshall, Northeastern, Ole Miss, Philander Smith, Rutgers, Stephen F. Austin, Tennessee State, Texas State, Troy, Tulsa, UNLV, UT-Arlington, Wake Forest, West Texas A&M, West Virginia, & William & Mary: 12 Points
- 87. Montana State: 11 Points
- T-88. Kentucky & Utah: 9 Points
- 90. Boston College: 8 Points
- 91. San Diego State: 7 Points
- T-92. Angelo State, Arkansas, Augustana, Austin Peay, Bethune-Cookman, Central Michigan Colorado Mesa, Delaware, East Carolina, Fresno State, Furman, Harvard, Houston, Iowa, Lambuth, Livingstone, Maryland, Miami (Ohio), Midwestern State, Mississippi State, Missouri, Missouri Southern, Monmouth, Mount Union, Navy, Nevada, New Mexico, Northern Iowa, Portland State, Prairie View, Rice, Santa Clara, SE Louisiana, SMU, South Carolina State, Southern Miss, UMass, Villanova, Wabash, Western Carolina, & Winston-Salem State: 6 Points
- 133. Bowling Green: 5 Points
- T-134. Auburn & Baylor: 4 Points
- 136. Missouri Western State: 3 Points
- T-137. Long Beach State, Texas A&M Commerce, Toledo, & Weber State: 2 Points
- 141. Coast Guard: 1 Point